Case Study · Historic Inn & Restaurant · Haubstadt, IN
Indiana's Second-Oldest Liquor License — and Both Menu Pages Are Named “blank”
Nisbet Inn — Haubstadt, IN · nisbet-inn.com
Indiana's second-oldest liquor license, established 1912. New owners since March 2026. Both menu pages are still at /blank and /blank-1 — Wix's default placeholder names, never renamed.
Live right now
The Evidence
The lunch menu — the single most important page on any restaurant website — is accessible at nisbet-inn.com/blank. That's Wix's factory-default placeholder URL, assigned when a page is created and never renamed.
The dinner menu is at nisbet-inn.com/blank-1 — the second Wix placeholder URL. Both menus are photos of handwritten paper. No hours anywhere on the site. No contact information. No history mentioning the 1912 liquor license.
The Business
Nisbet Inn at 6701 Nisbet Road in Haubstadt, Indiana — near Evansville — carries a credential that no competitor in the region can claim: the second-oldest active liquor license in Indiana, dating to 1912. That's 114 years of serving the community, through Prohibition, through two World Wars, through every shift in the dining landscape. The building, the license, the history — all of it is a marketer's dream.
In March 2026, new owners Brent and Kathy Weatherwax — of Pappa Bears Catering — took over the Nisbet Inn, bringing fresh energy, a catering background, and the motivation that comes with being new owners determined to make something their own. They inherited the history, the license, the reputation, and the website.
The website's menu pages are named /blank and /blank-1.
The Smoking Gun: Menu Pages Called “blank”
The two most important pages on any restaurant website — the menu pages — are accessible at the following URLs on nisbet-inn.com:
https://www.nisbet-inn.com/blank
https://www.nisbet-inn.com/blank-1
Those are the Wix platform's default placeholder page names — assigned automatically when a new page is created and never updated. The lunch menu is at /blank. The dinner menu is at /blank-1. Both pages contain only photographs of a handwritten paper menu on a white background — no searchable text, no visible pricing on mobile, no web-native menu at all.
A customer who visits nisbet-inn.com to see the menu — the single most common reason people visit a restaurant website — is clicking a link called “blank” to see a blurry photo of a handwritten piece of paper. For an establishment with the second-oldest liquor license in Indiana, this is an almost perfect inversion of the story the brand deserves to tell.
Why the Timing Is Perfect
Brent and Kathy Weatherwax took over Nisbet Inn in March 2026 — just months ago. They're in the window every new business owner goes through: excited about what they're building, aware that things need to change, and not yet locked into every decision the previous owners made.
They inherited a site that still reflects the old owners' minimal setup. The /blank menu URLs, the handwritten menu photos, the absence of hours, the missing contact information — none of that was their choice. It's just what was there when they arrived.
New owners who are actively building their vision for a 114-year-old institution are exactly the kind of clients who understand why the website matters. Pitchcraft found them at the right moment.
The Rest of the Audit
Beyond the /blank menu URLs, the site has several additional gaps that collectively make it hard for new customers to even confirm Nisbet Inn is currently open:
No Hours Listed
There are no hours anywhere on the site. A customer who finds Nisbet Inn on Google and wants to know when to come in has no way to find out from the website. They have to search further — and some of them won't bother.
No Contact Information
No contact email, no contact form, no phone number visible on the homepage. For a restaurant catering operation run by new owners eager to book events, the inability to easily get in touch online is a direct cost.
Menus Are Just Photos of Paper
Even setting aside the /blank URL names, the menu “pages” are photographs of handwritten paper menus on a white background. On a smartphone — which is how most customers are browsing — those images are tiny, hard to read, and impossible to search. If prices or items change, someone has to rephotograph the paper menu and re-upload the image.
The 1912 Story Is Invisible
Indiana's second-oldest liquor license is the kind of historical credential that makes Nisbet Inn genuinely distinctive — a reason to visit that no competitor in the region can claim. It's not prominently featured anywhere on the current site. New customers who don't already know the history have no way of discovering it.
What We'd Build
Our spec redesign for Nisbet Inn treats the 1912 history and the new ownership energy as dual assets — honoring the legacy while building something fresh that Brent and Kathy can call their own.
Hero — Lead With 1912
A full-width hero that opens with the credential: “Indiana's Second-Oldest Liquor License. Serving Haubstadt Since 1912.” That's a sentence that stops people in their tracks. The history is the brand — it deserves to be the first thing every visitor sees.
Web-Based Menus — Not Photos of Paper
Actual HTML menus for lunch and dinner — searchable, mobile-readable, easy to update when items or prices change. Accessible from clearly labeled navigation links, not Wix default placeholder URLs. The menus Nisbet Inn's customers actually need.
Hours, Contact, Reservations
Current hours on the homepage and a dedicated contact page with phone, email, and a reservation or inquiry form. Every friction point between a curious customer and a confirmed table — removed.
Catering Page
Brent and Kathy come from Pappa Bears Catering — that expertise is a genuine differentiator. A dedicated catering page with inquiry form, sample menus, and capacity information turns the new owners' background into an active revenue stream the old site never captured.
The 1912 History Page
A dedicated history page that tells the full Nisbet Inn story — the 1912 license, the Prohibition era, the decades of community service, and the 2026 chapter with Brent and Kathy. This is the kind of storytelling that turns first-time visitors into regulars and regulars into advocates.
The Impact
Nisbet Inn has an extraordinary story to tell and new owners who are motivated to tell it. The current site — with its /blank menus, missing hours, and invisible history — isn't telling any story at all. A redesign that surfaces the 1912 credential, presents the menus properly, and makes it easy to book a table or catering inquiry would deliver a direct return in new customer acquisition and event bookings.
The timing is ideal: Brent and Kathy are three months into their ownership. The decisions about how Nisbet Inn presents itself online are still being made. A website that reflects what they're building — not what was there when they arrived — is exactly the right investment at this moment.
The Pitch
Pitchcraft Agency builds spec redesigns for local restaurants whose websites don't match the quality of what they offer. We found Nisbet Inn — Indiana's second-oldest liquor license, new owners with a catering background, and menu pages literally named /blank — and built the concept ourselves. Our offer: a full website redesign, ongoing management, and marketing support as a recurring service. No multi-month proposals. Just a site that finally tells the Nisbet Inn story the way 114 years of history deserves.
See What We'd Build
We built the full spec redesign for Nisbet Inn. Book a free 30-minute call to see it.
Book a Free CallSee what we'd fix on your site
We'll review your website top to bottom, record a 10-minute Loom walkthrough of exactly what's broken, and deliver a PDF report with prioritized fixes — in 48 hours.
No commitment. No pitch deck.