Case Study
Smile Craft Louisville
Louisville, KY
189 five-star reviews and 17 years of great dentistry — and the “Featured on WHAS11” badge on the homepage links to WHAS11's news archive, not an actual segment.
Live right now
The Evidence
The homepage features a prominent 'Featured on WHAS11 — Louisville's Best Dental Practice' media badge. Clicking it routes to whas11.com/news — WHAS11's general news archive. There is no story, segment, article, or mention of the practice reachable from that link. The endorsement badge leads nowhere.
The homepage of smilecraftlouisville.com features a prominent media badge: “Featured on WHAS11 — Louisville's Best Dental Practice.” It's designed to look like a third-party editorial endorsement from Louisville's ABC affiliate. When clicked, it routes to the WHAS11 news archive landing page — not to any specific story, segment, or mention of the practice. The endorsement badge links to the station's front door.
The Practice
Smile Craft Louisville has been practicing cosmetic and general dentistry since 2009. 189 Google reviews. 4.7 stars. Porcelain veneers, Invisalign, teeth whitening, implants — a full cosmetic menu backed by a genuine patient satisfaction track record. 17 years of Louisville patients who chose this practice and stayed.
A practice with those credentials doesn't need borrowed social proof. The real story — 189 reviews at 4.7 stars, 17 years of cosmetic work — is more compelling than any media badge. But the badge is what's displayed prominently, and the badge raises a question it can't answer.
What We Found
A media badge that looks credible on first glance and falls apart on second.
The Badge Links to a News Archive, Not a Segment
The “Featured on WHAS11” badge, when clicked, routes to:
whas11.com/news
This is WHAS11's general news section — the same page any visitor would reach by clicking “News” in the station's navigation. There is no story, no segment, no article, no mention of Smile Craft Louisville anywhere reachable from that link. The badge clicks through to a page that has nothing to do with the practice.
The Credibility Cost of Unverifiable Claims
A prospect doing due diligence — the kind of patient who actually Googles before booking cosmetic dentistry — will click that badge. They'll land on a generic news page with no mention of the practice. At that point, the badge doesn't build credibility; it costs it. The question is no longer “was this practice actually featured?” — it's “why does this practice need to display a badge that doesn't go anywhere?”
The Real Credentials Are Buried
189 reviews. 4.7 aggregate rating. 17 years in Louisville. A full cosmetic portfolio including veneers, Invisalign, and implants. These are real, verifiable, impressive credentials — and they're not the first thing on the homepage. The unverifiable media badge is. The actual trust signals are positioned below it, secondary to a badge that undermines them.
What We'd Build
A cosmetic dentistry site built on credentials that hold up — where the first thing a prospect sees is a reason to trust that can't be clicked into doubt.
189 Reviews as the Lead Credential
A live Google reviews feed above the fold — 189 reviews at 4.7 stars is a strong signal that more patients rate this practice excellent than don't rate it at all. That's the real social proof. It should be the first thing a prospective cosmetic patient sees, not a media badge that goes nowhere.
Cosmetic Portfolio That Shows the Work
Before/after galleries organized by procedure — veneers, whitening, Invisalign, implants. Patients choosing cosmetic dentistry are buying a visual outcome. A portfolio that shows real patient results is more persuasive than any media badge.
17 Years in Louisville — Prominently
A practice that's been doing cosmetic dentistry in Louisville since 2009 has survived every change in the local market: competitors who opened and closed, insurance changes, economic cycles. That longevity is itself a credibility signal. It should be in the hero copy, not on an About page that most visitors never reach.
Spec Redesign Deliverables
- ✓Unverifiable media badge removed — replaced with live 4.7-star Google reviews feed
- ✓“17 Years of Louisville Cosmetic Dentistry” hero headline above the fold
- ✓Before/after gallery organized by procedure (veneers, Invisalign, whitening, implants)
- ✓Service pages for each cosmetic offering with patient journey descriptions
- ✓Online consultation booking with procedure-specific intake questions
The Opportunity
Louisville's cosmetic dentistry market is competitive. Patients choosing cosmetic procedures are making high-consideration, high-cost decisions — they research carefully and they notice inconsistencies. A patient evaluating whether to spend $3,000 on veneers will click every link on the homepage.
Smile Craft has 17 years of real results and 189 real patients who left positive reviews. That's a better story than any media badge. A site built around the real credentials — patient reviews, procedure portfolio, years in practice — converts at a higher rate than one built around social proof that raises questions.
The work speaks for itself. The website should let it.
See what we'd fix on your site
We'll review your website top to bottom, record a 10-minute Loom walkthrough of exactly what's broken, and deliver a PDF report with prioritized fixes — in 48 hours.
No commitment. No pitch deck.